You’re OK I thought it’d be more brilliant. Either way. I’m still happy.
BEAUTIFUL!!!! My husband and I love this coin. It is stunning!
QULITY VERSUS COST = SORT OF OKAY
Beautiful found 3 that I didn't have
Superb looking coin thank you
Couldn't load pickup availability
Guaranteed Safe & Secure Checkout | SSL Certified

Two Varieties, One Story: Compare the whimsical curve of the "Fancy 5" with the rarer, straighter "Plain 5" and discover how a tiny detail created a lasting numismatic mystery.
Over 150 Years of History: Minted in 1865 from 95% copper, these coins survived the post-Civil War era and now offer a tangible connection to America’s past.
Collector’s Double Feature: A perfect side-by-side set in Good to Very Good condition, ideal for enthusiasts who appreciate subtle minting quirks and vintage charm.
Travel back to the Reconstruction era of American history with this captivating 2-piece set of 1865 Indian Head Cents, featuring both the intriguing "Fancy 5" and the elusive "Plain 5" varieties. Struck during a time of national recovery and change, these copper coins are more than just currency—they're tangible relics of a bygone era, offering collectors a glimpse into the nuanced artistry of 19th-century minting.
What makes this set truly special is the subtle yet fascinating difference in the numeral “5” of the date. The "Fancy 5" showcases a more decorative, curved top, while the "Plain 5" bears a straighter, simpler design. Though small, this variation has sparked decades of collector interest—and the "Plain 5" is estimated to be about twice as rare. Having both in one set allows you to compare these varieties side by side and appreciate the detail that defines vintage American coinage.
Each coin is composed of 95% copper and is preserved in Good to Very Good (G–VG) condition, retaining much of its original charm and character despite the passage of more than 150 years. The coins come safely housed in protective flips, ready to be admired or displayed as part of your growing collection.
Whether you're an experienced numismatist or a curious history enthusiast, this set is a rich and rewarding addition. Add these classic Indian Head Cents to your collection today and own a distinctive piece of American minting lore.
All users of this site agree that access to and use of this site are subject to the following terms and conditions and other applicable law. If you do not agree to these terms and conditions, please do not use this site. We strive to ship all package within 7 business days of full payment of order (except in the case of a preorder), however, due to the inherent nature of unique collectible products, at times this might not be possible. Because of the nature of the Internet, online ordering your purchase from CoinsTV acknowledges that you have read and agree to these terms and conditions.
CoinsTV Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) PolicyAll order changes or cancellations must be reported prior to shipping and by phone on 1-833-482-6467. Returns must include a Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) Number. The RMA number can be obtained from our Customer Service department at 1-833-482-6467. All calls requesting RMA should be in the time designed for them (10:00 AM to 6:00 PM Monday through Friday EST, excluding the national and religious holidays). Collectible coin and packaging items may be returned for a replacement or a complete refund with 30 days of receipt of the order. Bullion items are final sale items and are not returnable. All returned orders may be subject to quality, authenticity and originality tests by CoinsTV testing facility or by a third party authorized by CoinsTV. Upon the explained test(s) results, nondefective items may be subject to a 20% restocking fee. CoinsTV reserves the right to refuse any request or actual return, exchange or refund if it does not meet our stated terms. For our full Shipping and Returns policy, please visit the Shipping Policy in our footer.
Subscribe to get special offers,
free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.
The coin was exactly what CoinsTV said it would be, except for one thing: I am sending it for grading as it appears to be Proof Like. I am delighted and grateful
Fantastic
Beautiful coins, so glad to add it to my collection.
Great show and watched it off and on now for about three years. And will continue.
I enjoyed the show very much. The host is always on top of his game. Yes, we need more shows like this! Thanks for asking.
You’re OK I thought it’d be more brilliant. Either way. I’m still happy.
BEAUTIFUL!!!! My husband and I love this coin. It is stunning!
QULITY VERSUS COST = SORT OF OKAY
Beautiful found 3 that I didn't have
Superb looking coin thank you
